I have seen several of versions of this quintessential cake over the blogoshere, which jogged my memory. Back in the early 80's, when I was making this dessert, it was named for Robert Redford, the hunky guy at the time. There have been several names attached to this dessert, Better than Sex Cake, Lush, etc. Depending on your genre, you could call this cake Better than Brad Pitt, Ryan Gosling, or you fill in the blank with your favorite hottie. Believe, back then hottie wasn't even a word. Which celebrity makes you drool?
This dessert is Oh My Goodness! good. It has four layers of heavenly flavors and textures. The first layer is a nutty, buttery crust, The second layer is cream cheese, powdered sugar, and whipped topping, mixed together. The third layer is instant chocolate pudding made with less milk, so it is firmer. The final layer is more whipped topping and and garnished with mini chocolate chips, chocolate curls, or chopped nuts, to name a few. One bite of this luscious dessert will have you in another universe.
You can make this dessert ahead of time, and put it in the freezer. I recommend putting the dessert in the freezer before cutting. As you will see my piece if the cake isn't perfect, because I didin't leave it in the freezer long enough before cutting. I was in a hurry to take pictures, before the light was gone, and I was going to Bunco, too. At night I dream of making perfect stunning, desserts, but it never seems to happens, I need to be more organized, and plan better, but that never seems to happen, either. Perfect or not, this dessert is out of this world. You can change up the pudding flavors. I used to make this with Pistachio pudding at Christmas, or Lemon pudding in the Spring. This dessert with the lemon pudding was my Mom's favorite. Whichever pudding you choose, you have to make this dessert, and savor every bite. Enjoy!
I had a PDF copy of the recipe from my old cookbook, but I couldn't convert it to aWord
document.
Better
Than Robert Redford Cake From Allstate Community Cookbook, Circa
1983
Ingredients:
***1st
Layer, the crust **
1 cup flour
1 cup pecans or walnuts, chopped
1/2 cup butter, softened i stick
***2nd layer the
cream cheese layer***
1 package (8 ounce size) cream cheese, softened
1 cup powdered sugar
1 cup Cool Whip
***3 rd
layer, the pudding layer***
2 small pkg Instant chocolate pudding., or flavor of your choice
2 small pkg Instant chocolate pudding., or flavor of your choice
3 cups milk I used Almond Milk
***4th
layer. the topping ***
1 cup Cool Whip
Mini chocolate chips, chopped nuts, or chocolate curls
Directions:
Preheat oven to 375 degrees F.
Mix ingredients for 1st layer, the crust, spread on bottom of an ungreased 9 x13 baking dish. Bake for 15 minutes. Cool thoroughly.
Mix the ingredients for the 2nd layer the cream cheese layer,, and spoon on top of cooled crust. Mix the ingredients for the 3rd layer, the pudding layer, and spoon on Top of 2nd layer. Chill for 30 minutes
Mix ingredients for 1st layer, the crust, spread on bottom of an ungreased 9 x13 baking dish. Bake for 15 minutes. Cool thoroughly.
Mix the ingredients for the 2nd layer the cream cheese layer,, and spoon on top of cooled crust. Mix the ingredients for the 3rd layer, the pudding layer, and spoon on Top of 2nd layer. Chill for 30 minutes
4th layer, top with a thin layer of
Cool Whip, and garnish with grated mini chocolate chips, chopped nuts, or,
chocolate curls. Freeze or refrigerate
overnight for easier cutting. I would definitely recommend leaving in the
freezer overnight for easier cutting. I didn’t
leave mine in the freezer long enough.
I linked up my recipe to Brandie@The Country Cook's Weekend Potluck #62
Stop by and say Hi to Brandie!
I linked up my recipe to Brandie@The Country Cook's Weekend Potluck #62
Stop by and say Hi to Brandie!
....now all I can think about is the hunkiness that was Robert Redford in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid...mmmmmmm
ReplyDeleteanyway...
OMG CAKE! This looks super drool worthy!
Kayle,
DeleteI also drooled over Paul Newman, but that's for another day! This dessert is outstanding in every way! is
I was always the Paul Newman fan. :) I'd forgotten all about this cake. I'll bet Dudette would love it.
ReplyDeleteChristiane,
DeleteI had forgotten about this cake, too. I love paaul Newman's eyes:) Dudette would love this. You can also use Lemon pudding, which is outstanding, too. Then you would eat some:)
What a beautiful cake!! Love the combinations of flavors!!
ReplyDeleteMr. & Mrs. P
Thank you! This cake is so good! You wouldn't be disappointed, if you make this.
DeleteDang that sounds and looks ridiculous! Favorite Robert Redford movie I would have to say is Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid! Thanks for sharing
ReplyDeleteHappy Blogging!
Happy Valley Chow
Eric,
DeleteThis cake is over top. I could eat the whole thing! Very dangerous, that's why I keep it in the freezer.
This cake looks absolutely delicious :D
ReplyDeleteCheers
Choc Chip Uru
Uru,
DeleteThis cake is amazing, and you should try it.
Hm.. this cake sure would be better than robert redford to me.. :))) I wouldn't risk trying this cake if it's really so good :D
ReplyDeleteMedja,
DeleteTake the risk and make the cake. It will be worth it:)
This looks like heaven! LOVE it. Pinned!
ReplyDeleteDorothy,
ReplyDeletethis cake is Oh My Goodness! good. If you make it, please let me know, how you liked it.
Thank you for your sweet words, and stopping by my blog.
Becky, I've never heard of this cake in any rendition, but oh my, it looks scrumptious! Loved the history of the dessert too...thank you for sharing the recipe.
ReplyDeleteBrooks,
DeleteThis recipe is an oldie but a goodie, so it was probably before your time. It is luscious though.
I've always seen it called Better Than Sex cake but, whatever you call it, it does sound dreamy. It's on my list of things to make... :)
ReplyDeleteAnita,
DeleteWhatever you call this dessert, it is scrumptious. If you do make this. please let me now how you liked it.
What cute names this cake has. When I return home, I will try baking one. Thanks for the recipe.
ReplyDelete